Click here to Skip to main content
15,887,135 members

Welcome to the Lounge

   

For discussing anything related to a software developer's life but is not for programming questions. Got a programming question?

The Lounge is rated Safe For Work. If you're about to post something inappropriate for a shared office environment, then don't post it. No ads, no abuse, and no programming questions. Trolling, (political, climate, religious or whatever) will result in your account being removed.

 
GeneralRe: The times they are a changing... Pin
jschell26-Mar-24 12:29
jschell26-Mar-24 12:29 
GeneralRe: The times they are a changing... Pin
Mike Hankey26-Mar-24 13:02
mveMike Hankey26-Mar-24 13:02 
RantI hate something I know nothing about... PinPopular
Jeremy Falcon23-Mar-24 5:59
professionalJeremy Falcon23-Mar-24 5:59 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... PinPopular
Richard MacCutchan23-Mar-24 6:15
mveRichard MacCutchan23-Mar-24 6:15 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Jeremy Falcon23-Mar-24 6:19
professionalJeremy Falcon23-Mar-24 6:19 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Richard MacCutchan23-Mar-24 7:05
mveRichard MacCutchan23-Mar-24 7:05 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
pkfox23-Mar-24 22:20
professionalpkfox23-Mar-24 22:20 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Amarnath S23-Mar-24 7:54
professionalAmarnath S23-Mar-24 7:54 
Jeremy Falcon wrote:
Why can't we not have an opinion on something we know little about?


Am reminded of an incident a few decades back, in India, with a renowned Physics professor, and a traditionalist (read ancient Indian tradition).

The Physics Professor was giving a public lecture, and routinely mentioned that tradition is all incorrect. In the audience was this long practitioner of tradition, and he got up and said openly that "Your physics is incorrect". The Physics Prof got angry, and here is the conversation that ensued in that lecture hall.

Physics Prof: Do you know the history of physics, where so many great physicists have discovered facts. How can you say that Physics is incorrect. You are unscientific. You don't have a scientific bent of mind. You don't understand Physics. You have not studied Physics, and have no right to comment on Physics.

Traditionalist: You say that you are a scientist. From what I know, Science has these steps - Theory, Experiment, Observation and Inference. Yes, I agree that Physicists have propounded theories about Mechanics, Heat, Acoustics, Optics, Electricity, etc. and have done experiments, made observations and only then have they made inferences about the theory propounded. And you have studied all of this, and done experiments, made observations, over several years/decades.

Traditionalist (continuing): Now, coming to my tradition, what theories have you studied? What experiments have you done, and what are your observations? Without doing any study, experiment or observation, how could you jump to the Inference stage and conclude that "My tradition is incorrect"? You have not studied the scriptures about tradition.

Traditionalist (continuing): Did it not occur to you to apply your own scientific principles in the study of tradition also? Having spent none or very little time in the study of Theory of tradition, having not even attempted any Experiment, without any Observation, how can you adversely comment in a public forum about tradition? Did you give yourself the right to do so? You are not a real scientist. If you are merely expressing your opinion, then it is not science, if it has no backup of theory, experiment, or observation, because it is not based on facts. In fact, it is you, the so-called Physics Professor, who is not having a scientific bent of mind. A real scientist should have an open mind about all fields of enquiry, and should have no prejudices or biases against anything. Yes, I intentionally said that "Your Physics is wrong", but only to show your absence of logic, scientific thought, scientific temper. I have spent years, decades, and have done serious enquiry, questioning about my tradition, consulted several experts, and have done several assessments about it; of which you have not even an idea.

The Physics Professor could not reply.
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Jeremy Falcon23-Mar-24 9:36
professionalJeremy Falcon23-Mar-24 9:36 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Richard Andrew x6423-Mar-24 13:50
professionalRichard Andrew x6423-Mar-24 13:50 
JokeRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Peter_in_278023-Mar-24 13:58
professionalPeter_in_278023-Mar-24 13:58 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Richard Andrew x6423-Mar-24 14:03
professionalRichard Andrew x6423-Mar-24 14:03 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Greg Utas23-Mar-24 15:53
professionalGreg Utas23-Mar-24 15:53 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Peter_in_278023-Mar-24 17:18
professionalPeter_in_278023-Mar-24 17:18 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Jeremy Falcon24-Mar-24 4:36
professionalJeremy Falcon24-Mar-24 4:36 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
JudyL_MD25-Mar-24 3:57
JudyL_MD25-Mar-24 3:57 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Jeremy Falcon26-Mar-24 10:31
professionalJeremy Falcon26-Mar-24 10:31 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Greg Utas23-Mar-24 15:59
professionalGreg Utas23-Mar-24 15:59 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Amarnath S23-Mar-24 18:51
professionalAmarnath S23-Mar-24 18:51 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
haughtonomous24-Mar-24 22:25
haughtonomous24-Mar-24 22:25 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Amarnath S25-Mar-24 1:07
professionalAmarnath S25-Mar-24 1:07 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
haughtonomous27-Mar-24 21:40
haughtonomous27-Mar-24 21:40 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
pkfox25-Mar-24 0:25
professionalpkfox25-Mar-24 0:25 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
kmoorevs23-Mar-24 9:33
kmoorevs23-Mar-24 9:33 
GeneralRe: I hate something I know nothing about... Pin
Jeremy Falcon23-Mar-24 9:50
professionalJeremy Falcon23-Mar-24 9:50 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.