Click here to Skip to main content
15,888,527 members

Bugs and Suggestions

   

General discussions, site bug reports and suggestions about the site.

For general questions check out the CodeProject FAQs. To report spam and abuse Head to the Spam and abuse watch. If you wish to report a bug privately, especially those related to security, please email webmaster@codeproject.com

 
AnswerRe: paging and size Pin
Brisingr Aerowing7-Nov-12 8:19
professionalBrisingr Aerowing7-Nov-12 8:19 
AnswerRe: paging and size Pin
Chris Maunder7-Nov-12 11:10
cofounderChris Maunder7-Nov-12 11:10 
SuggestionMissed post Pin
geoyar6-Nov-12 9:46
professionalgeoyar6-Nov-12 9:46 
GeneralRe: Missed post Pin
Pete O'Hanlon6-Nov-12 9:52
mvePete O'Hanlon6-Nov-12 9:52 
SuggestionFailing Link to Article Pin
Bram van Kampen5-Nov-12 12:44
Bram van Kampen5-Nov-12 12:44 
GeneralRe: Failing Link to Article Pin
Chris Maunder5-Nov-12 14:29
cofounderChris Maunder5-Nov-12 14:29 
SuggestionDeleting questions in Q&A Pin
Richard MacCutchan5-Nov-12 3:31
mveRichard MacCutchan5-Nov-12 3:31 
GeneralRe: Deleting questions in Q&A Pin
BillWoodruff5-Nov-12 16:27
professionalBillWoodruff5-Nov-12 16:27 
Hi Richard,

I interpret what you said, above, as advocacy for making questions on QA have a "never-delete" status, when someone has responded to the OP with a "significant" response that includes valuable information: if that's correct, I agree: those posts should not deleted. Whether you define both comments, and answers, as, possibly, "significant," I am not sure.

I do know I have seen some comments on QA questions that contained very useful content for me !

The "structural" problem I see is: if the question is trivial, its title indicative of its lack of substance or confusion, or the question's content is absurdly weird, then the "valuable response" will, probably, get "lost in the ozone," even if the question "sticks." And, then, you have the issue of: what if a lot of other high-rep people don't think the question, and its comments/answers, don't deserve to "stick" ?

A forum for Asian expats I participate in has a fixed rule that once any reply has been given to a post by another member, the OP cannot delete the question, but, I am not saying I think that's best for CP.

What I really enjoy seeing on QA is the degree to which many responders can use their vast experience to respond to what the user really means to ask, but what they were incapable of asking articulately. imho, people like you, and OriginalGriff, and many others, are masters of knowing the question that really needs to be answered.

In addition to the OP behavior you describe, your point here also brings to mind, for me, whether I (or others), as would-be-helper, should ever delete an OP (given we have the rep level to delete questions).

It does "gall" me if I see a question, followed by multiple responses (as comments) trying to get the OP to clarify, tag, frame, the question, followed by "radio silence" by the OP, or the OP responding to very precise clarifying questions by just restating their original question ("yes, but how do I bind a ... to a ... ?").

Equally "galling" to me, is to see one or more good answers which the OP never marks as an answer.

I have been extremely reluctant to "kill" a QA question (I'm not sure, in fact, if I've ever done this). I've certainly felt like doing this, after I've posted a series of clarifying questions, and gotten the kind of non-response I just described by an OP.

So, how would this work on a practical level ? Should someone with a certain level of rep be able to set an asked question, with what they view as significant response(s), to "never-delete" status.

I have proposed, on this forum, before, that: if an OP doesn't respond to comments asking them, politely, to clarify, tag, frame, etc., their question, within a certain period of time, those with platinum rep should be able to "freeze" the question from being answered until the OP responds to the comment(s).

The sad fact is: if many of the QA questioners simply knew how to use CP search, they'd find their common questions ("how do I make a change to the Text in the TextBox on Form2 available to ... whatever ?") have already been answered many times. imho, that's an intractable problem Smile | :)

And, the question of how to "harvest," and save in a convenient, accessible, well-indexed, way, great technical content that appears on both QA, and, in places like the Lounge, is one that continues to intrigue me: there's no practical solution I can see that would not require massive effort on the part of CP staff which is totally impractical.

My only practical response to this scenario is that I have sent several QA responders who've given what I felt were unusually great answers (and several Lounge posters), my thanks, and a suggestion they post their content in the form of a Tip/Trick, or, even an article.

best, Bill
~
Confused by Windows 8 ? This may help: [^] !

GeneralRe: Deleting questions in Q&A Pin
Richard MacCutchan5-Nov-12 22:17
mveRichard MacCutchan5-Nov-12 22:17 
GeneralRe: Deleting questions in Q&A Pin
wizardzz5-Nov-12 16:34
wizardzz5-Nov-12 16:34 
SuggestionCould we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
BillWoodruff5-Nov-12 2:45
professionalBillWoodruff5-Nov-12 2:45 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Slacker0075-Nov-12 8:01
professionalSlacker0075-Nov-12 8:01 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Pete O'Hanlon5-Nov-12 8:41
mvePete O'Hanlon5-Nov-12 8:41 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Slacker0075-Nov-12 9:11
professionalSlacker0075-Nov-12 9:11 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Pete O'Hanlon5-Nov-12 9:19
mvePete O'Hanlon5-Nov-12 9:19 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Slacker0075-Nov-12 9:23
professionalSlacker0075-Nov-12 9:23 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
fjdiewornncalwe5-Nov-12 9:33
professionalfjdiewornncalwe5-Nov-12 9:33 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Slacker0075-Nov-12 9:34
professionalSlacker0075-Nov-12 9:34 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Jörgen Andersson5-Nov-12 9:52
professionalJörgen Andersson5-Nov-12 9:52 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Slacker0075-Nov-12 9:59
professionalSlacker0075-Nov-12 9:59 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
BillWoodruff5-Nov-12 16:32
professionalBillWoodruff5-Nov-12 16:32 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Jörgen Andersson5-Nov-12 20:28
professionalJörgen Andersson5-Nov-12 20:28 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Pete O'Hanlon5-Nov-12 10:22
mvePete O'Hanlon5-Nov-12 10:22 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
Slacker0075-Nov-12 23:31
professionalSlacker0075-Nov-12 23:31 
GeneralRe: Could we keep politics and religion out of the Lounge ? Pin
BillWoodruff5-Nov-12 15:16
professionalBillWoodruff5-Nov-12 15:16 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Flags: Answered

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.