Click here to Skip to main content
15,891,745 members

Survey Results

Do you run under an administrator account on your main work machine?   [Edit]

Survey period: 2 Mar 2009 to 9 Mar 2009

We all know it's safest if you don't. But they say that about a lot of things. (Suggested by 3dit)

OptionVotes% 
I run with administrator access1,38582.83
I used to run as administrator, but no more301.79
I run certain programs as administrator, but my login isn't an administrator account1036.16
I run as administrator only when required by the OS (eg installs)1317.83
I never have administrator access on my machine231.38



 
RantI run as admin only when needed on my dev machine, always on test machine Pin
Jakob Bohm10-Mar-09 1:51
Jakob Bohm10-Mar-09 1:51 
GeneralCouldn't do my job otherwise Pin
Foghorn226-Mar-09 10:36
Foghorn226-Mar-09 10:36 
GeneralDeveloper schizophrenia... Pin
Palavos4-Mar-09 21:42
Palavos4-Mar-09 21:42 
Generalproject Pin
gadzluvall4-Mar-09 5:05
gadzluvall4-Mar-09 5:05 
GeneralRe: project PinPopular
0x3c04-Mar-09 20:47
0x3c04-Mar-09 20:47 
GeneralRe: project Pin
Vasudevan Deepak Kumar6-Mar-09 22:23
Vasudevan Deepak Kumar6-Mar-09 22:23 
AnswerAmbiguous question Pin
dj_jeff3-Mar-09 5:18
dj_jeff3-Mar-09 5:18 
GeneralRe: Ambiguous question Pin
Vikram A Punathambekar3-Mar-09 6:28
Vikram A Punathambekar3-Mar-09 6:28 
GeneralRe: Ambiguous question Pin
FocusedWolf6-Mar-09 1:29
FocusedWolf6-Mar-09 1:29 
I don't see your point about vista or windows 7 aka vista because if you're an admin user, it's the same as Xp with the exception of the delay in the execution time because vista waits for the user to say... yes, twice (double clicking the program was the first time), that they want to run a program that needs admin just to run, but that is of no concern to the user, (but it probably is for the many that disable UAC)...

Look their are programs that ask for UAC elevation, and go ahead with drastic actions like disabling system firewalls, and spawning other processes with elevation... in the end the scheme failed. And i'm sure their are programs that just add entries into the vista firewall whenever they feel like...(btw why have a way for a program to add itself to your firewall because it wants access... what was the point... just a security leak)

What microsoft should of done was just guard actions that might harm the system as they occur... not a "continue" "cancel" at the start of a program. So if internet explorer wants to format your harddrive, you warn the user when that occur and tell them why... right?

Another thing m$ could of done was a way to classify applications when you install, and also rely on known libraries of programs for what they need... for example if you install a webbrowser, it shouldn't ever need the sorta stuff a harddrive defragmenter needs, and it should never need to write to a system folder... so why ask the user to let it... I mean their could just be three types of programs,..."system" (needing high privileges + access to modify system files), "utilities" (needing high privileges but never modifies system files) and "application" (needing low privileges). So 99% of the programs you install should be at the low "application" level.

Also an "Unknown" mode for programs the user has no idea about... where you should be allowed to execute the program, and also recieve all elevation requests (not block any, like if the type of program-type-filter was set)... and tell the user the action that is to occur.

And to round this all off.. and option about how much to nag so that if a program like notepad tries to format windows, that if the type of program was set to "Application", that do you want to still be allowed to make a choice... in short a way to disable the application filter... the alternative is the program is terminated on the spot with a readout of what happened. What it was going to do.
GeneralVista with no UAC Pin
Luis Alonso Ramos3-Mar-09 4:20
Luis Alonso Ramos3-Mar-09 4:20 
GeneralBut I frequently test with a regular user on another PC Pin
Rosenne2-Mar-09 22:30
Rosenne2-Mar-09 22:30 
GeneralRe: But I frequently test with a regular user on another PC Pin
BloodBaz5-Mar-09 0:59
BloodBaz5-Mar-09 0:59 
GeneralMake a distinction between domain admin and local admin Pin
Krissh2-Mar-09 20:22
Krissh2-Mar-09 20:22 
GeneralYes Pin
Member 41348902-Mar-09 11:36
Member 41348902-Mar-09 11:36 
GeneralRe: Yes Pin
CPallini3-Mar-09 9:50
mveCPallini3-Mar-09 9:50 
GeneralRe: Yes Pin
John M. Drescher5-Mar-09 7:46
John M. Drescher5-Mar-09 7:46 
GeneralRe: Yes Pin
roger.orr5-Mar-09 11:55
roger.orr5-Mar-09 11:55 
GeneralRe: Yes Pin
Pharago8-Mar-09 17:31
Pharago8-Mar-09 17:31 
GeneralUntil they come with developer rights... Pin
Yusuf2-Mar-09 8:05
Yusuf2-Mar-09 8:05 
GeneralRe: Until they come with developer rights... Pin
yassir hannoun2-Mar-09 12:35
yassir hannoun2-Mar-09 12:35 
JokeRe: Until they come with developer rights... Pin
Viral Upadhyay2-Mar-09 18:13
Viral Upadhyay2-Mar-09 18:13 
GeneralXP is a pain / Vista's smooth Pin
Mark J. Miller2-Mar-09 4:55
Mark J. Miller2-Mar-09 4:55 
GeneralRe: XP is a pain / Vista's smooth Pin
Indivara2-Mar-09 14:30
professionalIndivara2-Mar-09 14:30 
GeneralUmmm... yes? Pin
PIEBALDconsult2-Mar-09 4:52
mvePIEBALDconsult2-Mar-09 4:52 
GeneralRe: Ummm... yes? Pin
Ravi Bhavnani2-Mar-09 7:02
professionalRavi Bhavnani2-Mar-09 7:02 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.