C / C++ / MFC

12-Feb-08 4:30

Hi
Can anybody help me with the following puzzling problem?

I have created a dialog using Visual Studio 2005 (MFC) and added a combo box to it. This combo has been set to type Drop List and I have set the list box height at design time by clicking the arrow and changing the height of the "ghost" image. I have also set the Vertical Scroll to True.

I have populated this with more items than should be possible to display in one go. However, when I run it, no scroll bar appears!!! That is, it simply drops down with all the entries.

Can anybody tell me what I've done wrong and ideally reproduce the problem as I'm going slightly crazy!!!

Thanks

Paul

Iain Clarke, Warrior Programmer12-Feb-08 5:05

12-Feb-08 5:05

I just did what you described, and had no trouble. It behaved as expected. So something else in your application is giving you trouble.

Are these just CComboBoxes? Or CMyCustomCombo?

Does it work on a freshly created dialog app project? If so, what are you doing differently?

Are you handling some fancy CBN_MEASURESTUFF notification and doing odd sums?

I'm just guessing now...

Iain.

Iain Clarke appearing in spite of being begged not to by ^CPallini.

Davros12-Feb-08 5:15

12-Feb-08 5:15

Hi Iain

No, it is just a normal combo. Not handling anything. Very strange! I've tried it on two different machines (reproducing my steps) and get exaclty the same thing.

I've given the combo a variable i.e. m_comboBox and fill it using

m_comboBox.AddString(_T("Hello World")); etc

Is there any code in particular I could cut and paste to show what I've done?

Paul

Davros12-Feb-08 5:20

12-Feb-08 5:20

Here's a copy of the resource:

IDD_DIALOG1 DIALOGEX 0, 0, 186, 90
STYLE DS_SETFONT | DS_MODALFRAME | DS_FIXEDSYS | WS_POPUP | WS_CAPTION | WS_SYSMENU
CAPTION "My First Dialog"
FONT 8, "MS Shell Dlg", 400, 0, 0x1
BEGIN
DEFPUSHBUTTON "OK",IDOK,129,7,50,14
PUSHBUTTON "Cancel",IDCANCEL,129,24,50,14
CONTROL "Radio1",IDC_RADIO1,"Button",BS_AUTORADIOBUTTON,21,14,38,10
COMBOBOX IDC_COMBO2,22,39,57,14,CBS_DROPDOWNLIST | CBS_SORT | WS_VSCROLL | WS_TABSTOP
END

Iain Clarke, Warrior Programmer12-Feb-08 5:56

12-Feb-08 5:56

I just peeked at my resource, and I got:

COMBOBOX  IDM_TOOLS_MEASUREMENTANGLE,36,8,60,116,CBS_DROPDOWNLIST | WS_VSCROLL | WS_TABSTOP

There are two differences: CBS_SORT, which we can ignore, but I almost never use, and the cy value.

You have 22,39,57,14 and I have 36,8,60,116. Try editing yours to be a medium value (eg) 80, and see how you get on.

Your may be so small, windows is going "With the edit box, I can't even see one drop down. I'd better just show the lot". That would be a surprise, but not a shock. Probably some fix to be compatible with a program under Windows 3.0.

Iain.

Iain Clarke appearing in spite of being begged not to by ^CPallini.

Davros12-Feb-08 6:00

12-Feb-08 6:00

Hi Iain

I tried your suggestion and still no luck. Very strange! This was done on VS 2008 but I get exactly the same thing in Visual Studio 2005.

Here's my dialog code:

// TestDialog.cpp : implementation file
//

#include "stdafx.h"
#include "mfc2008combodroplist.h"
#include "TestDialog.h"

// TestDialog dialog

IMPLEMENT_DYNAMIC(TestDialog, CDialog)

TestDialog::TestDialog(CWnd* pParent /*=NULL*/)
: CDialog(TestDialog::IDD, pParent)
{

}

TestDialog::~TestDialog()
{
}

void TestDialog::DoDataExchange(CDataExchange* pDX)
{
CDialog::DoDataExchange(pDX);
DDX_Control(pDX, IDC_COMBO1, m_comboBox);
}

BEGIN_MESSAGE_MAP(TestDialog, CDialog)
END_MESSAGE_MAP()

// TestDialog message handlers

BOOL TestDialog::OnInitDialog()
{
CDialog::OnInitDialog();

// TODO: Add extra initialization here

m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("G"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("D"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("G"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("G"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("D"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("G"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("G"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("D"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("G"));
m_comboBox.AddString(_T("A"));

return TRUE; // return TRUE unless you set the focus to a control
// EXCEPTION: OCX Property Pages should return FALSE
}

and the header:

#pragma once
#include "afxwin.h"

// TestDialog dialog

class TestDialog : public CDialog
{
DECLARE_DYNAMIC(TestDialog)

public:
TestDialog(CWnd* pParent = NULL); // standard constructor
virtual ~TestDialog();

// Dialog Data
enum { IDD = IDD_DIALOG1 };

protected:
virtual void DoDataExchange(CDataExchange* pDX); // DDX/DDV support

DECLARE_MESSAGE_MAP()
public:
CComboBox m_comboBox;
virtual BOOL OnInitDialog();
};

Davros12-Feb-08 6:07

12-Feb-08 6:07

Ah, I tried adding loads and loads of entries, so that the list won't fit on the screen and a scrollbar appears!

However, this isn't what I want. Obviously when the list box size is set in the resource editor the whole point is that it shouldn't be any bigger than intended.

I'm very puzzled but very grateful for the help your giving!

Paul

Iain Clarke, Warrior Programmer12-Feb-08 6:18

12-Feb-08 6:18

I made a virgin project, added a box, and it worked as we'd both expect. If you email me your address, I can zip it and send it. (Obviously don;t post it here). It is a VC6 project though. Which made me look at your post again, and I saw...

the line "#include "mfc2008combodroplist.h", makes me suspicious...

Maybe MFC is being naughtily helpful?
Are you under Vista, and it's being "helpful" too?

Have you tried editing the resource as I recommended and setting the CY value as something medium? (ie, well above 14!)

Iain.

Iain Clarke appearing in spite of being begged not to by ^CPallini.

Davros12-Feb-08 6:31

12-Feb-08 6:31

Hi Iain

The include is merely the name I gave the application. I don't think it has anything to do with it because I had a different name on the Visual Studio 2005 version.

I'm using XP and Vista. The problem is on both.

Yep, I changed the CY value without any luck.

This is a strange one!!!!

Paul

p.s. I've sent you an email

Davros12-Feb-08 7:02

12-Feb-08 7:02

Hi Iain

I've just tried to do the same thing in VC++ 6 and it works!!!

This is obviously an issue with VS2005!

I'm amazed there aren't more posts on the issue though. Surely others have encountered it!!!

Paul

Davros12-Feb-08 7:47

12-Feb-08 7:47

HOWEVER - when I load the VC++ 6 project into Visual Studio 2005 it WORKS!!! OMG | :OMG:

Paul

Iain Clarke, Warrior Programmer12-Feb-08 9:03

12-Feb-08 9:03

My bet is that it's a difference MCF'S combobox. I bet MFC v2005 is doing clever things - and the imported project is using mfc42.dll.

Try not using CComboBox as a member variable and DDX_Controlling.

Try using SendDlgItemMessage (CB_ADDSTRING.... etc)

Iain.

Iain Clarke appearing in spite of being begged not to by ^CPallini.

Davros12-Feb-08 9:13

12-Feb-08 9:13

that's sounds sensible to me!

I'll give it a go and post if it works.

It does sound like a bug though doesn't it?

Paul

Davros13-Feb-08 0:12

13-Feb-08 0:12

Hi Iain

I'm afraid I did't make much progress with your suggestion using SendMessage i.e. deadlines etc. However, I would like to thank you again for all your hard work in helping me with this problem.

Paul

David Crow12-Feb-08 7:49

David Crow

12-Feb-08 7:49

Davros wrote:
That is, it simply drops down with all the entries.

If all of the items are there, what's the problem? Confused | :confused:

"Normal is getting dressed in clothes that you buy for work and driving through traffic in a car that you are still paying for, in order to get to the job you need to pay for the clothes and the car and the house you leave vacant all day so you can afford to live in it." - Ellen Goodman

"To have a respect for ourselves guides our morals; to have deference for others governs our manners." - Laurence Sterne

Davros12-Feb-08 9:11

12-Feb-08 9:11

lol - well, because (1) the code isn't doing what it should and (2) you get list box which extends a large area and looks ugly.

(1) is the most important thing you - don't you agree?

Sensor accessing

SnaKeBeD12-Feb-08 4:18

SnaKeBeD

12-Feb-08 4:18

Hi all,

I have a project to be done by this week!! i have a fingerprint censor from which i have to access the finger print data. Hoew do i access that data from that device. Drivers for the device is installed and can anybody help me to find some links and tutorials for accessing Hardware in MFC???

Please help me with some useful stuffs...

Thanks in advance

Smile | :)

||SnAkeBed||

Matthew Faithfull12-Feb-08 4:28

Matthew Faithfull

12-Feb-08 4:28

One key piece of information that may help people to help you is - how is the scanner attached to your PC, Serial cable, USB, FireWire, VMEBus, Bluetooth, WLAN 802.11.g &c
Once we've got that figured out I'd almost certainly suggest not writing the device communications stuff directly into your MFC app. Create a separate plain C++ Dll and possibly a stand alone test app to load it up and give it some exercise.
If you end up having to write a driver for your device remember there's a whole Driver Development Kit you can download from Microsoft with sample code and the like. Standards documents are also useful if you're dealing with a device that has to conform to some spec like USB or Ethernet.

Nothing is exactly what it seems but everything with seems can be unpicked.

SnaKeBeD12-Feb-08 4:35

SnaKeBeD

12-Feb-08 4:35

hi,

Thanks for ur reply

Its a USB Device and the driver for the device is already installed.so i think there is no need of writing a seperate driver for that.

Since i'm new to this subject can u please help me in providing some links for accessing a USB device

Thanks in advance

Smile | :)

||SnAkeBed||

Cedric Moonen12-Feb-08 4:44

Cedric Moonen

12-Feb-08 4:44

The way to work with USB devices is to first get the handle to the driver by calling the CreateFile functions. Once you have the handle, you can start exchanging data with the device by calling ReadFile and WriteFile (passing the handle). You can also exchange specific IO control codes with the driver by calling DeviceIOControl.

That's from a high level overview. You should have received documentation with the driver itself describing how to use it the driver (what are the IO control codes you can exchange with it, which name you need to pass to the CreateFile function in order to retrieve the handle of the driver, ...).

Cédric Moonen
Software developer

Charting control [v1.2]

Matthew Faithfull12-Feb-08 4:57

Matthew Faithfull

12-Feb-08 4:57

Here are a few links that Google threw up, I've not done any talking to non disk USB devices myself so these are definitely used at your own risk.

http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms792232.aspx[^]

http://today.java.net/lpt/a/303[^]

http://www.componentsnotebook.com/notebooks/csharp/deviceio.aspx[^]

http://www.eix.co.uk/Ethernet/USB/[^]

Nothing is exactly what it seems but everything with seems can be unpicked.